In Utah, when police find a gun and drugs on the same person, the gun is often the bigger problem. A small amount of marijuana is usually a misdemeanor. The gun charge that comes with it can be a felony.
In June, the U.S. Supreme Court decided United States v. Hemani. It gives people charged under Utah's version of this law an argument they did not have before. It does not make the charge go away by itself. This article covers what the case decided and what it means for Utah.
What Happened in Hemani
Ali Hemani lived with his parents in the Dallas area. In 2022 federal agents searched the family home for reasons that had nothing to do with drugs or guns. Mr. Hemani turned over a gun he kept in the house, showed agents some marijuana, and told them he used marijuana about every other day. Prosecutors charged him under the federal law that makes it a crime for anyone who is an "unlawful user" of a controlled substance to have a gun. The charge carried up to 15 years in prison.
The government never claimed he was addicted or that he was high when he had the gun. It did not claim his marijuana use made him dangerous. Its position was that regular drug use, by itself, was enough to take away his right to have a gun.
The Supreme Court disagreed. Under the test the Court now uses for gun laws, the government has to show that a law fits the country's historical tradition of gun regulation. The government pointed to old laws aimed at "habitual drunkards." The Court said those laws targeted people whose drinking left them unable to manage their own affairs, and they usually gave a person some kind of court process before taking away any rights. The federal law, as the government read it, disarms anyone who regularly uses any amount of any illegal drug, automatically, with no hearing. The Court held that prosecuting Mr. Hemani on that basis violated the Second Amendment.
What the Court Did Not Decide
The Court did not strike down the federal law. It ruled on this prosecution of this man. It said it was not deciding whether the government can disarm people who are addicted or people who are intoxicated while they have a gun. It also left open a prosecution backed by evidence that a particular person's drug use makes him dangerous, and it did not touch the law that bars people with felony convictions from having guns.
So the line, for now, looks like this. A gun charge built on nothing more than regular drug use is in serious trouble. A charge that comes with more, like proof the person was high or addicted, is a different case, and Hemani does not decide it.
Utah Has Its Own Version of This Law
Utah law makes certain people "restricted persons" who cannot have a gun. Two parts of that list involve drugs. One covers anyone who is an unlawful user of a controlled substance. The other covers anyone who has a gun or other dangerous weapon while knowingly possessing an illegal drug from Utah's two most serious drug schedules, which include marijuana, methamphetamine, heroin, cocaine, and fentanyl.
For a restricted person, having a gun is a third degree felony, punishable by up to five years in prison. Having some other dangerous weapon is a class A misdemeanor.
The Second Amendment limits the states the same way it limits the federal government. Utah prosecutors are bound by Hemani just as federal prosecutors are.
What Changes for a Utah Charge
Hemani does not erase the Utah law. Prosecutors can still file these charges, and the decision does not dismiss a pending case on its own. What changed is the defense. A person charged under the drug-user part of the Utah law can now ask the judge to dismiss the charge as applied to him, and that request is strongest when the only evidence is that he uses drugs.
That part of the Utah law reads almost the same as the federal law the Supreme Court just limited. If a Utah prosecutor charges someone who uses marijuana and keeps a gun at home, with no evidence he was high or addicted and nothing showing he was a danger to anyone, I think that charge is unlikely to survive. That was Mr. Hemani's case.
The other part, a gun and drugs at the same time, is a closer call. Prosecutors will argue it punishes conduct, having both together, rather than who a person is. The defense answer is that it still takes away a constitutional right automatically, with no finding that the person was dangerous or impaired. I have not found a Utah appeals court decision applying Hemani to either part of the Utah law yet. Expect those cases over the next year, and the Legislature may decide to change the law before the courts finish.
The Case on the Other Side
Guns and drugs are a dangerous combination, and prosecutors and legislators have real reasons to worry about it. The Court itself said its decision should not be read to mean that legislatures can never disarm groups of people who present a special danger of misusing guns. It left room for laws aimed at people who are intoxicated or addicted, and for prosecutions backed by proof that a particular person's drug use makes him dangerous. Expect prosecutors to start building those cases.
What Has Not Changed
Possessing illegal drugs is still a crime, and carrying a gun while selling drugs is still treated very seriously under both state and federal law.
The federal form you fill out when you buy a gun from a dealer still asks whether you use illegal drugs. Lying on that form is its own federal crime, and Hemani does not change that.
If you have a Utah medical cannabis card and stay within its limits, state law protects that possession, which matters for a state charge. Federal law does not recognize the card.
If You Have Been Charged
Do not plead guilty to a restricted person gun charge until a lawyer has looked at it with Hemani in mind. The facts that matter are specific: what the police can actually prove about your drug use, whether there is any evidence you were impaired, where the gun was, and what you said.
That last one matters most. Mr. Hemani's whole case was built on his own statement to agents that he used marijuana about every other day. Do not answer questions about your drug use, or anything else, without a lawyer.
If you were already convicted, whether Hemani helps you is a harder question that depends on how your case ended. It is still worth asking.
Charged With a Gun and Drug Offense?
I defend restricted person and drug cases in Salt Lake City and across Utah. Free consultation.
(801) 641-0883 Send a MessageThis article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Contact an attorney to discuss your specific situation.