← Back to Blog

These are the questions I hear on the first phone call, and the ones people search for before they call anyone. The short answer comes first. Every case is different, so treat this as general information and call me about yours.

Jail, Cost and Whether You Need a Lawyer

Will I go to jail?

It depends on the charge, your record, and what the State can actually prove. Anyone who promises an answer on the first call is guessing. What I can tell you right away is the most a court could impose and what usually happens on a charge like yours. In Utah a class B misdemeanor carries up to six months in jail and a class A up to a year. Many first-time misdemeanor cases end with probation and no jail. Felonies carry prison ranges, and I go through yours with you at the start. More on misdemeanors and felonies.

How much does a criminal defense lawyer cost?

I tell you the cost before any work starts. The price depends mostly on how serious the charge is and whether the case is likely to go to trial. Most defense lawyers charge either one flat fee for the case or an hourly rate, so ask which one and ask what it covers. The first conversation with me is free.

Do I really need a lawyer for a misdemeanor?

You are allowed to handle it yourself. Before you do, know that a quick guilty plea is still a criminal conviction. It shows up on background checks for jobs, apartments and professional licenses unless it is later expunged. A lawyer reads the police reports first and finds out what the prosecutor can prove. Call before your first court date, even if you decide to go alone.

Should I hire a lawyer or use the public defender?

If you cannot afford a lawyer, you have a right to a public defender, and many of them are good lawyers. They also carry very heavy caseloads. If you are able to hire someone, what you are paying for is time on your case and a lawyer who picks up the phone.

If I did it, why do I need a lawyer?

What happened and what the State can prove are two different questions. The charge that gets filed is often heavier than the facts support. A lawyer checks whether the stop, the search and your statements hold up, then works on the charge and the sentence. That work can decide whether you keep your job or your driver's license.

Police and Arrest

The police want to talk to me. Should I?

No. Ask for a lawyer and stop talking. When police ask you questions they are gathering evidence, and explaining yourself almost never makes a case go away. You can say, “I am not going to answer questions without my attorney.” Asking for a lawyer does not make you look guilty to a judge. Read why you should not talk to police.

A detective called and says he just wants my side of the story. What do I do?

Take down the name and number, say your lawyer will call back, and end the call. A call like that usually means you are being investigated. No lawyer is appointed for you until you are charged, so this is when people do themselves the most damage. Read what to say when police contact you.

I was just arrested, or someone I love was. What do we do first?

Say nothing about the case to police. Write down what happened while it is fresh, and save every text, photo and video. If the court ordered no contact with someone, follow that order exactly, even if the other person reaches out first. Then call a lawyer before the first court date. I answer calls and texts at night and on weekends.

Can the person who called the police drop the charges?

No. In Utah the prosecutor decides whether a case goes forward. That is true in a domestic violence case even when the other person wants it dismissed. Cases do get dismissed or reduced when the evidence is weak or was gathered unlawfully, which is why the police reports get read before anything is decided. Read how a 911 call becomes a domestic violence case.

Court and Your Record

What happens at my first court date?

The judge tells you what you are charged with, asks whether you have a lawyer, and sets or reviews the conditions of your release. On a misdemeanor you may be asked how you plead. You do not have to settle the case that day. Pleading guilty just to get it over with is a mistake I see often.

Should I take the plea deal?

Not until someone has read the evidence. The first offer often comes before your side has seen the police reports and the video. Sometimes the offer is fair and taking it is the smart move. I will tell you which it is and why. The decision is always yours.

How long will my case take?

It depends on the charge and the court. Misdemeanors usually move faster than felonies, and a case that goes to trial takes the longest. Once I have seen the evidence I give you a realistic timeline.

Will this stay on my record?

A conviction stays on your record and shows on background checks unless it is expunged. Many Utah records can be expunged after a waiting period, and some felony convictions can be reduced to a lower level first. I handle both. Expungement of a qualifying misdemeanor is a $500 flat attorney fee. Read about expungement and conviction reductions.

I was arrested for DUI. Is there a deadline I need to know about?

Yes, and it is short. You have 10 calendar days from the day the officer gives you the notice, which is usually the day of the arrest, to ask the Driver License Division for a hearing. If you do not ask, the suspension of your driver's license goes ahead without one. This is separate from the court case. Read about the 10-day deadline.

Hiring Jim

Will you handle my case yourself?

Yes. Call and you get me. I am a solo lawyer. The person you talk to on the first call is the person who reads your file, deals with the prosecutor and stands next to you in court.

What kinds of criminal cases do you take?

Felonies, sex crime charges, domestic violence cases, DUI and misdemeanors, in Utah state courts and in federal court in Utah. Before I opened my own firm I worked at a Salt Lake City criminal defense firm on serious felony cases, including a felony jury trial. Tell me the charge when you call. If I am not the right lawyer for it, I will help you find one who is.

Is it true you were convicted of a crime yourself?

Yes. I was convicted of robbery and disbarred in 2005. I did not practice law for twenty one years. I retook and passed the Utah bar exam and was readmitted to the Utah State Bar in 2025. I know what it is to wait for a court date and to stand in front of a judge as the defendant. Read my story.

Where do you take cases?

Mainly in Salt Lake, Utah, Davis, Weber, Summit and Tooele counties. Ask me if your case is somewhere else in Utah.

Is what I tell you confidential if I do not hire you?

Yes. What you tell me on the first call is confidential, whether or not you hire me.

English is not my first language. Can I still call?

Yes. You can call with an interpreter. You can also text me in Spanish or Arabic at (801) 641-0883 and I will text back in the same language. I speak German.

When should I call a lawyer?

As early as you can. The best time is before you talk to police and before your first court date. The call is free: (801) 641-0883.

Have a Question That Is Not Here?

The first conversation is confidential and free.

(801) 641-0883 Send a Message

This article is for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this page does not create an attorney client relationship with Tily Law LLC. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.